on landscape The online magazine for landscape photographers

Pinhole Follow Up

Putting it into Practise

Tim Parkin

Tim Parkin

Amateur Photographer who plays with big cameras and film when in between digital photographs.

Flickr, Facebook, Twitter



Following on from my previous article on pinhole photography I decided to create my own film pinhole photographs using a large format camera and a converted Copal 1 shutter (I removed the lens elements and inserted my pinhole, mounted on a suitably sized circular plastic sheet, into the back of the shutter). This conversion allowed me to try some full frame 5x4 pinholes and also some 6x12 pinhole photographs using a Horseman back.

At the end of this instalment, I am also going to give a few links to books, photographers and resources that will help you along.

To begin with, my experience of pinhole photography was quite intriguing. There wasn’t much ‘accurate’ framing going on. On most pinhole cameras you get ‘lines’ that show you the field of view for your camera. On my large format conversion, I had a couple of choices. Firstly, I could use an equivalent focal length lens to check my composition if this didn't match the focal length I could just stop it down to get an idea of the framing. This won’t be 100% accurate for the frame edges (because many modern lenses don’t have the exit pupil at the same plane as the lens board) but could help get the balance of a picture right.

Secondly, I could take the pinhole out of the back of the copal shutter and check the position of my corners using the 'chopped' corners on my ground glass. In the end, neither of these techniques were 100% satisfactory and I came to the conclusion that a camera with diverging line markings to show the field of view is a pretty good compromise and fits with the philosophy of pinhole photography e.g. see the Reality So Subtle camera below.

RealitySoSubtle 6x12 Camera (link)

With my 5x4 camera I was unable to take exceptionally wide photographs, the widest I could manage was approximately 60mm (equivalent to about 16mm on full frame 35mm cameras). The light fall-off on these photographs should be about two stops, which looks about right based on the results I got.

The Results

What surprised me most was just how sharp some of the results were. If you are one of those people who characterise pinholes as generally blurry or having an out of focus look, think again. In this particular photograph of Achnambeithach at the bottom of the three sisters, the detail in the house is quite incredible considering there is no lens involved.

In fact, the detail is probably too much and a few people commented that if you want sharp photographs shouldn’t you be using a lens? Well, that’s a pretty good argument but the pictures do have a certain aesthetic that I haven’t seen from a straightforward optical photograph. I surmise that there is probably a sweet spot in terms of film size and this is probably in the medium format territory. I'll probably make or buy a 6x12 camera with masks.

Here’s another photograph look directly at the Three Sisters in Glencoe and displaying the flare that is characteristic of pinhole photography. These ‘rays’ are presumably tiny reflections from the imperfections in the pinhole (which goes to show you that even a £55 hole isn’t aberration free). Also, with flare in mind, you are still best to shade the pinhole if the sun is outside of the field of view of the photograph as light rays can still be bounced onto the film via these imperfections.

Here’s a photograph that is about as wide as I could get with the large format setup, taken from the bridge over the river Coe at the bottom of the three sisters.

Another surprising thing that I discovered whilst developing and scanning these photographs is the amazing latitude of Ilford HP5! I overexposed most of the photographs by at least two stops (in order to ensure no blocking up in the corners) and yet the highlights were clearly captured on film without excessive grain, witness the Three Sisters photograph looking directly into the sun with the shaded hills.

Here are a couple of results using the Horseman 6x12 back on the Ebony.

I have to say I'm very pleased with the results from the pinhole photographs I have taken so far and will be looking at making or purchasing a simple box camera pinhole when I get a chance.

Resources for the Pinhole Photographer

Whilst I was putting together the article on pinhole photography, I invested in a few books to research the genre. Here are a few favourites.

Pinhole Photography by Eric Renner (2008)

An excellent treatise on the history, techniques and application of pinhole photography. A must buy for those interested in pinhole photography.

ISBN: 978-0240810478

The Pinhole Camera by Brian J Krummel(2009)

Covers a lot of ground including things like how to develop film and also includes some very nice pinhole work in a gallery in the back

ISBN: 978-1442187665

The f/D Book of Pinhole by Kier and Libby Selinsky (2016)

A global survey of pinhole photography. A digital print book with an eclectic collection of practitioners represented.

ISBN: 978-0692837337

Poetics of Light by Eric Renner and Nancy Spencer (2014)

A very well put together and varied portfolio covering a wide range of practitioners and techniques.

ISBN: 978-0890135884

I also looked around at various websites and here is a selection of ones I found useful.

And finally, you can find some calculators on the Mr Pinhole website.

 



  • David Cary

    Lovely article. Pinholes are not sharp in the same sense as a conventional digital file, but printed or viewed small they may be pretty sharp. Best thing about them, tonality, no digital artifacts, fun, photographers equivalent of making improvisational jazz or beating pots with a spoon. https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/b7e987d9e78109fe0583b6ba52d87c5ae76d3b83c8f9ee5455da60eb33dddee9.jpg

    • Tim Parkin

      Yeah that’s what I’ve realised. I’ll have to print a few out to get the proper measure of them. Nice shot – I like how the reflection in the water looks.

  • Robin Jones

    Enjoyed these 2 articles Tim. Thanks. I often take the pinhole camera on holiday for fun and leave the heavy bag at home. A change is as good as a rest and i find it relaxing, playful fun, with low expectations and great satisfaction when you make a strong image.

  • Wendy Chapman

    Nice article Tim. I think you have found the essence of pinhole – the adventure and freedom from absolute control. I recently purchased the RSS 6×12 and am having fun with it. I find the forgiveness of film quite a delight as well. Now to learn B&W developing.

On Landscape is part of Landscape Media Limited , a company registered in England and Wales . Registered Number: 07120795. Registered Office: 1, Clarke Hall Farm, Aberford Road, WF1 4AL